I have eaten lots of Caribbean Salt Fish Cakes but my friend Hyacinth, originally from Jamaica, definitely makes the very best Salt Fish Cakes in E17! They always ‘go like hot (fish) cakes’ when she brings them to church shared lunches. One thing that makes them particularly good are that they are crispy outside, soft inside and most importantly, unlike some I have tried, they are never ever greasy! I managed to get her recipe and I share it with you here…
The quantities given on the original recipe were approximate, so could be slightly increased to feed another person by adding a little more flour and another egg. The original recipe called for 8ozs flour and 2 eggs. I misread the original hand written recipe and I added finely chopped green pepper, but we liked the flavour and colour so I decided to keep it in. I also decided to slightly pre-cook and cool the onion and pepper, so it is properly cooked, as the eventual cooking time for the dish is not long. A squeeze of lemon juice, if you wish, helps enhance the flavour. Do not be tempted to add any more salt!

'Meanderings through my Cookbook' http://www.hopeeternalcookbook.wordpress.com
Hyacinth’s Salt Fish Cakes
(Serves 2-3 or 4+ as a starter)
5ozs/150g pack of boneless, skinless salt fish pieces (usually Pollack or Cod)
4ozs/125g Self Raising Flour
1 egg
1 small onion, very finely chopped
½ green pepper, very finely chopped (optional)
1tbsp tomato purée
Black pepper
1tsp lemon juice (optional)
Oil for frying
1. At least 1hour before you are going to make the fish cakes, place the salt fish in a bowl and cover with cold water. Change the water immediately and cover fish again with water. Leave for about one hour, changing the water once more.
2. If you have a microwave oven then place the finely chopped onion and green pepper together in a small bowl and cook, covered, for 1minute. Alternatively, cook together in a small saucepan with a little water over a low heat for 2-3 minutes until the liquid has evaporated. Do not let the onion and pepper start to colour. Put to one side and do not use until it has cooled – it can go in the fridge once it is no longer hot.
3. Drain the fish in a colander or sieve. As much water as possible should be squeezed out before the fish is used. Chop the fish as finely as possible, checking that there are no bones and removing them if necessary.
4. Break the egg into a large bowl and whip. Mix in the flour. Stir in the fish, tomato purée, onion, pepper, plus lemon juice if using, until well mixed. Draw the mixture together into a ball. If it is a little sticky then add some more flour if needed.
5. Form the mixture into 8 or 9 equal sized flattened cakes: 2 or 3 per person – depends on how many people you are feeding. If serving as a starter then divide mixture into smaller cakes.
6. Place in the fridge for 10 minutes or until ready to cook.
7. Heat a little oil in a frying pan and fry the cakes very gently until golden brown on both sides. Each cake will stick slightly but once it is set it can be turned easily. Allow the cakes to seal on one side before you turn them to avoid them breaking up. Keep warm under a gentle grill until needed.
8. Serve with Rice & Peas and Fried Plantain and a few green peas or some salad leaves.
Just found my new way to make fritters! I will use reg. tomatoes and add a dash of hotsauce next time. But I loved the lightness of this one!
—–
Welcome Daria – thank you for your comment:
My only concern about using fresh tomatoes would be that it could make the mixture rather too wet Tomato puree is useful as it adds concentrated flavour without too much liquid. I think I would want to add the hot sauce (good idea!) but would increase the puree a little for extra tomato flavour.
I am glad you enjoyed this lovely recipe. So many Caribbean fish cakes I have eaten are heavy and greasy but this is beautifully light, I agree.
Thanks again to my good friend Hyacinth!
h/e
I’m currently feeling a bit lazy for never having tried salt fish. I’m going to bookmark these and try to make them. I’ll let you know how they go.
—–
Hello Corina
I would not recommend using Salt Fish to anyone who doesn’t really like a strong fishy flavour but we like them very much and hope you do too. Do make sure you soak the fish thoroughly. Enjoy!
Ackee I have eaten at Caribbean buffets – usually served in the dish Salt Fish & Ackee – but I have never cooked with it. I know what you mean in your recent post when you say it doesn’t seem to have much flavour and looks like scrambled eggs!
h/e